mitchleblanc wrote:granite_grrl wrote:I'd think that Sean C's guide covers routes quite well, I wouldn't see the need to toss it into another book.
I haven't seen Sean's guide, and this comment doesn't relate to it at all:
Having an existing guide, no matter how good it is, doesn't preclude someone from writing a newer, better and more updated one, and certainly doesn't imply that the next guidebook author (and
certainly not Zig) is going to "toss" anything "into another book".
That kind of reasoning is a good cause for nothing evolving and developing.
Guide book writing doesn't develope routes. A guide book is a service to the community, routes, ethics and the like will still evolve and develope without one (heck, look how long NS went before Cassidy put out his and Zig started putting together the bouldering one).
I think that I am valid in saying that there is no
need to have this info in another book, and I was not saying that someone
shouldn't do up a new guide if they feel thay can come out with a "newer, better and more updated one". But Cassidy's guide is not yet outdated, it is not poorly done. New routes have been listed on Cassidy's website.
There is plenty of bouldering that a bouldering guide for NS will stand alone quite nicely, and I'm very excited to see the results.