Moderators: PeterA, chossmonkey, Stacey, Dom, granite_grrl, Greg, Joe
climbnb wrote:Sorry guys but mostly everything in here has already been done. Darrell found this quite a few years ago and we've been in a couple of times. (I'm sure he's been in more) Normally there is too much snow in there to make it worth while. But it looks like you timed it right!
Dee
Fred wrote:Good job Stacey, Greg, and Anders. A great find and thank you for sharing it with the climbing community.
Fred wrote:Is it just me or does anyone else get annoyed with these undocumented first ascents? If you don't care enough to take the time to document it, why take the time now, aside from just wanting to downplay someone else's achievements?
I can understand that some people prefer to climb for pure Zen ground-up without grades or documentation... but those people don't come back decades later to rain on someone else's parade.
Good job Stacey, Greg, and Anders. A great find and thank you for sharing it with the climbing community.
Fred wrote:Not to mention, was it snowing in those photos?
StaceyMJCouturier wrote: though I think the 21st of Feb was when Dom was climbing in Hampton on rock
Vive NB for sure - -
Fred wrote:Is it just me or does anyone else get annoyed with these undocumented first ascents? If you don't care enough to take the time to document it, why take the time now, aside from just wanting to downplay someone else's achievements?
I can understand that some people prefer to climb for pure Zen ground-up without grades or documentation... but those people don't come back decades later to rain on someone else's parade.
Good job Stacey, Greg, and Anders. A great find and thank you for sharing it with the climbing community.
climbnb wrote:Who is the keeper of this said 'documentation' and when did this forum become Gospel???
climbnb wrote:I suppose, since I don't read a lot of ice guide books I can put my name on some climbs out west as well!?
climbnb wrote:Does anyone really think that climbers who have been climbing in this area for upwards of 20+ years has not found this stuff?
climbnb wrote:NO ONE is trying to take away the work that Greg and company have done and no one is trying to 'hide' anything. In our humble opinions is was not worth sharing. Have at er'!
Joe wrote:Does all this also apply to bouldering? See "Boulder in Freddy. Is it done" - Sorry, the timing was too perfect, I couldn't resist.
Joe wrote:Does all this also apply to bouldering? See "Boulder in Freddy. Is it done" - Sorry, the timing was too perfect, I couldn't resist.
As a guidebook author, sometimes I didn't include ice routes because of their lack of significances. For example Tweedle Dee and Tweedle Dum on the old THC near Kingsclear, Moss Glen Falls on Kingston Penn., and the various small ice falls behind Truancy Falls. Fred, as an author I'm sure you also made decisions to not include some small routes in your book. As I said before, it's a matter of significances. I don't think anyone expects a guidebook to be the total and complete documentation of every single little climb ever done.
Regarding Glebe Rd, yes Darrell Steele had climbed there years ago, but he didn't think it deserved mention in a guidebook, so he didn't bother documenting it. (I think it was filled with snow at the time.) But now Greg and Stacey have brought the area to our attention and have assigned names to lines, so it is officially documented.
My intention is to provide an annual "New Ice Routes Update" at the end of each season in which I will compile any and all new routes submitted to this forum. I have complete confidence that members of this forum will analyze the list and express opinion at the slightest sniff of controversy. Who woulda thunk there'd be so much politics in climbing?
Joe wrote:Does all this also apply to bouldering? See "Boulder in Freddy. Is it done" - Sorry, the timing was too perfect, I couldn't resist.
....
My intention is to provide an annual "New Ice Routes Update" at the end of each season in which I will compile any and all new routes submitted to this forum. I have complete confidence that members of this forum will analyze the list and express opinion at the slightest sniff of controversy. Who woulda thunk there'd be so much politics in climbing?
Fred wrote:climbnb wrote:Who is the keeper of this said 'documentation' and when did this forum become Gospel???
A new ice guide was published just last year was it not? I don't see mention of these routes in there. If you wanted recognition for said routes, you know how to get in contact with Joe.climbnb wrote:I suppose, since I don't read a lot of ice guide books I can put my name on some climbs out west as well!?
That makes no sense. We are talking about undocumented, this means they are not recorded in a guide.climbnb wrote:Does anyone really think that climbers who have been climbing in this area for upwards of 20+ years has not found this stuff?
Since you bring it up.. this is my real beef with this issue. Contrary to what these veterans may think, there are many new areas and lines that have yet to be discovered. Sunnyside, Mt Misery, Cloudbase, Grand Manan, Kingston... the list goes on. These are just some of the new areas discovered recently. I'm tired of hearing blanket statements that everything has been climbed in New Brunswick at some point or another. That is far from the truth. In my opinion, we should be encouraging new prospectors to develop the areas NB has to offer, not down-playing their accomplishments.climbnb wrote:NO ONE is trying to take away the work that Greg and company have done and no one is trying to 'hide' anything. In our humble opinions is was not worth sharing. Have at er'!
Obviously this was not your intent, but it was the result. If it was not worth sharing, why did you bring it up now? That was the original question.
climbnb wrote:Oh, so you are just looking for an answer to a question Fred? Geez, I wish people were more specific about what I am allowed to say on this forum? I just need rules Fred, can you please post those? Also, remind me what the question is that I'm to answer. I forget now, can't see past all the beautiful flowers.....
)
climbnb wrote:Does anyone really think that climbers who have been climbing in this area for upwards of 20+ years has not found this stuff?
Dee
Joe wrote:As a guidebook author, sometimes I didn't include ice routes because of their lack of significances. For example Tweedle Dee and Tweedle Dum on the old THC near Kingsclear, Moss Glen Falls on Kingston Penn., and the various small ice falls behind Truancy Falls. Fred, as an author I'm sure you also made decisions to not include some small routes in your book. As I said before, it's a matter of significances. I don't think anyone expects a guidebook to be the total and complete documentation of every single little climb ever done.
anderfo wrote:This reminds me of the people that do inventions but don't tell anyone.
Say you invent the wheel, and you keep quiet about it until after another guy invents the wheel and everyone starts rolling on them. Do you then show up and tell them you invented it 50 years ago and want to patent it?
No, you cry because you forgot to tell people how to use wheels to make life easier. And if you are interested in money you go home and cry even more because you forgot to patent the wheel 50 years ago.
anderfo wrote:This reminds me of the people that do inventions but don't tell anyone.
Say you invent the wheel, and you keep quiet about it until after another guy invents the wheel and everyone starts rolling on them. Do you then show up and tell them you invented it 50 years ago and want to patent it?
No, you cry because you forgot to tell people how to use wheels to make life easier. And if you are interested in money you go home and cry even more because you forgot to patent the wheel 50 years ago.
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 16 guests