I had a chance to lead some of Welford's classics this weekend. It's funny how you always avoid climbing routes at your local crag because you hear so many storries about a particular route. But when you get on them they aren't nearly as bad as you expected. Here's my report on the following 4 Welsford classics that have bad reps (meaning scary or difficult).
Waterfall Layback
Beautifull route. Definitely 5.9 and no less. Great gear but heady at the top. I think this one still deserves the rep that it has as being a stout lead with good gear.
Slippery When Wet
Yup some of the clips (two of them) are a bit difficult. But the route is definitely not dangerous or scarry in my opinion. This route should see more traffic. I recommend climbing WF Layback and pre-hanging draws on the bolts when you rap down. Put a long runner 60cm on the first and fourth bolts and no problem. A beautiful line and I'll be back for this one. Could use a mild cleaning in one or two spots. I blew the onsight pumping out trying to clip the 4th bolt (the only bolt I didn't have a pre-placed draw go figure). You have to hang on a crazzy slopper to clip.
Grandpa's Demise
Yes it's runout but bolts are pretty much where you want them. I think a solid 5.10 leader can get through this one without any troubles. I was a bit disapointed in the quality of this route. I had heard great things about it so maybe my expectations were too high. Nonetheless, it's a great climb but maybe only (3.5stars/5stars). With the rockfall that occured at the bottom, getting to the first bolt is a bit sketchy. Be carefull.
Pink Panther
Great line but I was a bit tired by the time I got to this route. I'm sure I will enjoy it even more the next time around. I think the first 50ft of this route keep this line from being a Canadian classic. From the ledge onwards is spectacular. Pulling the roofs is easy and not nearly as exposed as the 'legend' says. If you lead 5.9 trad... giver. A must for all.
On another note...
I toproped Human Erazer. WOW!!! dude!!! That route deserves some climbing. I'm pretty sure I'll be back to Minkey to do this one. I put this one in the top 10 for Welsford. I didn't lead it but I did observe. I don't know if this route would be "R" rated. Great gear at your feet for the crux and I think there is gear after the crux before you continue to the top. The fall would be 15-20ft in my opinion on a bomber piece with tons of gear just below that bomber piece as well. I could be wrong though. I didn't lead it.